harry potter 2 parts good or bad (opinion?)

[Grayson91xp]

Part 1 was meant to make you feel like it was bad, after all it is right before all the fighting and dying of the greater characters and to people who read the books might realize the first was to give all the books info out so that the part 2 can be epic and more of a war movie

[MartinJohnstone]

Part 1 is all about building up the dread. Dumbledore is dead and the Death Eaters are running he country.

Harry, Ron and Hermione know what they have to do but have no idea where to start or what to do once they get he horcuxes. So the are basically wandering aimlessly.

Its this aimless and hopeless situation which needed a separate film to convey a one hour preamble would not have done it justice. nor would Dobby's death bean the f*ck You moment enough is enough needed to kick start the second movie.

My only concern is that Nevile s not sown as the complete bad-ass that he is.

[jaguarman134]

except instead of putting all of that in they just filmed the inside of a f*cking tent and cut stuff out that explained the story
they butchered dobbies death and them sneaking into the ministry